Contemplating Surah Al-A'raf: Episode Eight
In the Name of Allah, the Most Merciful
All praise is due to Allah, and may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, his companions, and those who follow them with righteousness. May the peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you.
In our previous session, we reflected upon Surah Al-A'raf at the verse:
"The good land produces its vegetation by the permission of its Lord; and the bad land produces nothing but scant, with difficulty." (Quran 7:57)
This example perfectly aligns with what we will discuss today regarding the stories of the Prophets. These narratives serve as examples of the struggles faced by humanity in its journey on this earth as it contends with falsehood. The human who follows what has been revealed to him from his Lord, who does not take other than Allah as a protector, and who seeks only the path of truth in this life—these stories, verses, lessons, and admonitions illustrate the beginnings and endings, and the harmony between premises and their consequences.
The stories of the Prophets with their peoples, the hardships and problems they faced in conveying the message of truth, and all that will be mentioned in this context perfectly align with the saying of Allah the Exalted:
"The good land produces its vegetation by the permission of its Lord."
Human Soul as Good and Bad Land
The human soul, whether as an individual or a community, resembles a society like good land—earth that is prepared after rain falls upon it, as mentioned in the verse preceding this one. It is ready to yield every good fruit, every blessing that Allah, the Exalted, has bestowed upon humanity. Why? Because it is fertile, arable land. As soon as the rain descends upon it, it produces those blessings that Allah has granted to mankind, for it is good land, not bad.
In stark contrast is the bad land, the salty, barren earth that is unfit for cultivation. No matter how much rain falls from the sky, it changes nothing; it revives nothing. As we mentioned earlier, Allah the Exalted says in the preceding verse:
"And it is He who sends the winds as good tidings before His mercy, until when they have carried heavy rainclouds, We drive them to a dead land and thereby bring it to life." (Quran 7:57)
In the first verse, He says "dead land", and in the second, "good land". Death and life, goodness and badness—these attributes apply not only to what Allah has created but also to us, as human beings.
There are people who are dead in their disbelief and distance from the path of Allah the Exalted. Disbelief is death—true death, a spiritual death, a death of that spiritual connection between man and his Creator. But what is life? Is life merely the physical existence within a body composed of clay? Or is the true life—which the Quran wants us to recognize—the life of the spirit, the life of the heart? And there can be no life for the spirit or the heart without faith. Disbelief kills man; it kills that great spirit with which Allah has honored and dignified man.
Thus, when Allah the Exalted describes attributes that apply to the land—dead land, good land, bad land, living, dead—these are attributes that also apply to us as human beings. The good heart, the heart that truly needs the rain from the sky—the rain of revelation, the words of revelation, the verses of the messages sent with the Prophets, faith in Allah the Exalted, and monotheism. When that rain—the rain of monotheism—revives it anew, it produces every good deed, word, or action. For faith gives meaning to deeds and words, making them acceptable to Allah the Exalted, and imbues every word or action with purpose and intention. This purpose and meaning is what gives value to those deeds.
In contrast stands the corrupt soul, or the bad land—or the earth, as we mentioned earlier, that no matter how much rain or water descends upon it, revives nothing, for it is dead. It can no longer receive the meanings of mercy contained in that rain.
Prophets' messages and monotheism call
What is the relevance between the hadith and the introduction to these verses regarding what the Qur'an will present in this surah concerning the mention of the messages of the prophets and the hardships and difficulties they faced with their peoples? The relevance is very clear. The messages of monotheism brought by the prophets were a single word: "Worship Allah; you have no deity other than Him." This word is like the rain that is sent and through which the prophet conveys his message to his people. All the prophets conveyed this message to their peoples. However, among these peoples, some may have a certain vitality, and when this word reaches them, it revives within them the meanings of devotion to the Creator, the Exalted. They have a pure disposition to accept the meanings of faith, which then bear good deeds, good words, and belief in the messages of the prophets, following the methodology that they brought.
Conversely, among humans, there are those who can never accept that message, even though the message is one, the water is one, the rain that descends from the sky is one. But the earth that receives and accepts that rain is different; some of it is good, and some of it is bad. Likewise, humans: all of them have been conveyed the message of the prophets. Some accept that message with faith and belief, while others have had their hearts sealed, rejecting that message outright, in its entirety and in detail.
And here, the stories begin—the stories of the prophets—to give us a model and a living example of what humans may encounter in their journey on this earth as they struggle against falsehood, seeking to achieve the truth embodied in those elite among creation, the prophets. Allah, the Exalted, begins in Surah Al-A'raf by mentioning Noah, peace be upon him. And in the verses, in every verse and every story, we will find dozens of situations that connect not only between those prophets in their journeys with their peoples and what our Prophet, may Allah's prayers and peace be upon him and his family, faced with his people, but also with humanity in general, in every time and every place, based on the methodology they choose to follow in their lives: the methodology of truth, the methodology of goodness, the methodology of the message of the prophets.
Therefore, our Lord, the Exalted, begins by saying: "We have certainly sent Noah to his people." And Allah, the Exalted, in all these stories that He will mention, chose from every people a messenger from among them. Why is the messenger from the people, from the same tribe, from the same clan? They knew him, they knew his lineage, they knew everything about his previous life before he conveyed the message, before the revelation descended upon him. Since they knew everything about his life, it was more fitting and appropriate that they be the first to believe in that message.
Every prophet was not a stranger to his people or to the tribe to whom he was commanded to convey the message; he was among them, he was from the midst of that group of humans, and they knew everything about him. Thus was our Prophet, may Allah's prayers and peace be upon him and his family; his tribe knew him, his family knew him, and they knew all the details of his life before the mission, so it was only right and proper that they be the ones to hasten to believe in the message. But the reality of life differs from this aspect.
Allah, the Almighty, says: "We have certainly sent Noah to his people, [who said], 'O my people, worship Allah; you have no deity other than Him. Indeed, I fear for you the punishment of a tremendous Day.'" The messages of the prophets were not complex messages; they were not based on principles or philosophies deeply entangled in complexity or inability to convey meaning directly and clearly to those they called. Never. The message was of profound depth, yet at the same time, it was of extreme simplicity, ease, and accessibility. It reached and addressed the consciences of humans, despite the varying differences in human minds and understanding.
We know that people differ in understanding, perception, ability to accept, communicate, and comprehend meanings. These different perceptions are a well-known reality among humans. Yet, all the messages of the prophets came to address people in general, which is a great matter indicating that this message was not from these prophets as individuals, but rather from the All-Knowing, the Most Kind, the One Who encompasses all knowledge, the One Who knows the nature of His servants, their levels, and their perceptions.
The message was clear: it came with the message of monotheism. And monotheism, despite the differences in what each prophet called his people to in the details, we find that some prophets focused on economic maladies prevalent in their peoples, others focused on moral deviations in behavior, and others on social deviations. Despite all these differences and variations in details, the fundamental call was the call to monotheism. It did not differ among all the messengers who preceded our Prophet, nor between the message of our noble Prophet, nor between all that we discuss regarding the call to monotheism.
This matter calls for us to pause and realize that the message of monotheism is a comprehensive message, a message that gathers the essence of virtues, a message capable of warding off all types of evils and corruptions, whether in the individual or society. Why? Because the word of monotheism in His saying, the Exalted: "Worship Allah; you have no deity other than Him" directs worship based on sincere devotion, which is the monotheism for Allah, the Exalted. This call is not a theoretical call, not an abstract example. Monotheism in the Qur'an is not an abstract example far removed from the reality of people. Indeed, the word of monotheism is "There is no god but Allah," but it is a methodology of life, a methodology of action, a practical application.
When a person directs his worship solely to Allah, the Exalted, without associating partners with Him, and purifies himself from the filth of polytheism and the various inclinations from which he derives his methodology in life, there is no doubt that this will bear all forms of righteousness. And all the corruption that appeared in all previous nations, as we will come to,—economic corruption, moral corruption, sexual deviations, all types of corruption—came in one way or another from the corruption of belief and the relationship between Allah, the Exalted, and that servant. Corrupting the relationship with Allah, corrupting it with polytheism, corrupting it with disbelief. When he corrupts it with disbelief, the heart and mind turn to other than Allah, the Exalted, taking besides Allah protectors who manage the affairs of his life, who manage his matters.
And when the methodologies—whether the methodology of fathers or grandfathers or various forms—become the driving force that moves a person in his journey and path on earth, other than the methodology of truth that Allah sent down with His prophets, that person cannot be guided. Undoubtedly, the deviations mentioned in the stories of the prophets will manifest from him. Therefore, the creed of monotheism was worthy of being the first and only word in all the stories with all the prophets and the peoples to whom they were sent.
Prophets' compassion and sincere intentions
What is also noteworthy is that the Prophet—here, Prophet Noah (peace be upon him)—is not harsh in his dealings with those he invites to the truth, despite calling them to what is good and righteous and urging them to abandon what is entirely evil in terms of shirk (associating partners with Allah) and other violations. Despite all this, he begins by demonstrating profound compassion for their humanity and innate nature:
"Indeed, I fear for you the punishment of a Great Day." (Quran 71:13)
The motivation that drives him to convey the message after Allah’s command is a human one: "I fear for you the punishment of a Great Day."
This Prophet and this elite group of humans were not driven by personal motives, interests, or desires to achieve self-glorification, fame, or elevated status among nations. The missions of the Prophets—all of them—were not undertaken to ensure that their names would be remembered. Many people who seek to enter history through its widest gates desire, in their claims and what they call others to, to build a monument of glory for themselves, ensuring that history records their names. However, this elite group of humans—including, of course, our Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him)—never considered their mission as one of building personal glory at the expense of the message.
Thus, the Quraysh were perplexed by the matter of our Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him). They openly said to him, seeking to bargain with him about his call, and attempting to negotiate with him:
"Do you seek a kingdom? We will make you a king. Do you seek wealth? We will give you so much wealth that you will become the wealthiest among us. Do you seek dominion and honor? We will honor you above us. What is it that you truly want?"
They confined all possible human motives to personal drives: the desire to build personal glory, wealth, fame, position, or authority. The feeling of power is also among such motives.
What they did not account for was the possibility that the true motive could be faith and answering the call of faith—a profound motive. In reality, this is a refinement for all reformers and callers, for all those engaged in noble and constructive projects in our societies. Define your goal. Determine the objective of that great reformative project, whether it is economic, social, educational, familial, or media-related. Strive to make your goal a lofty one, one not tied to personal interests, for all goals tied to personal interests will perish. Every goal tied to that great purpose—the purpose of Tawheed (monotheism)—will endure.
Thus, today, after hundreds of thousands of years—how many years have passed since Noah (peace be upon him)?—we still remember the names of these Prophets as we recite the Quran. Who glorified these Prophets? Who built for them a glory they themselves never sought to construct? How did these great names become names that are remembered, while none other than them are recalled? Consider that in the very next verse, it states:
"The elite among his people said, 'Indeed, we see you in clear error.'"
(Quran 7:60)
Who were the elite? What were their names? They have vanished from history; the only mention of them is that they were the elite. Meanwhile, these elite of creation, whose efforts were never directed toward raising a name, fame, position, or similar aspirations, have had their memories immortalized, their names enduring, and their verses recited throughout the world.
Role and fate of societal elites
It is worth pausing to reflect on this. True glory lies in what a person does purely for the sake of Allah. Every action not done purely for His sake will ultimately fade and perish. In every story and every verse about the Prophets, we encounter this phrase:
"The elite among his people said, 'Indeed, we see you in clear error.'"
"Al-Mala’" (الملأ): a group of influential people who hold authority, whose words are heeded, and who possess not only social standing but also a commanding presence in society—so much so that their appearance alone commands attention. They occupy a prestigious position.
However, social status, authority, and having influence and a prominent place among people will avail them nothing if they do not utilize what Allah has granted them in obedience and worship of Him. All these things will be taken away from them. Reflect with me on this proportion.
Allah the Exalted, at the beginning of Surah Al-A’raf, says:
"And We have certainly established you upon the earth and made for you therein ways of livelihood. Little are you grateful." (Quran 7:10)
Here, He mentions the elite:
"The elite among his people said, 'Indeed, we see you in clear error.'"
(Quran 7:60)
Who enabled these elite? Who granted them sustenance on earth? Who gave them strength, protection, physical prowess, wealth, and knowledge? Who?
At the same time, the address is directed at the Quraysh, for among the people most opposed to the truth throughout history—and including in the message of Islam—are the elite, the influential faction in society. They act as a barrier preventing people from receiving the message of truth. The greatest obstacle between the Prophets and the realization of their call to reform and methodology.
Thus, the verse in Allah’s statement:
"The elite among his people said..."
(Quran 7:60)
applies equally to the Quraysh. They confronted you, O Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him and his family), but their fate will not differ from that of previous nations. It is an established law of Allah that applies to all these nations: the power and ability granted to them by Allah, if used in disbelief, disobedience, and obstructing the path of Allah, will bring about their ruin.
Allah the Exalted and the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) first address this in the Quran, addressing all of us, at the beginning of Surah Al-A’raf:
"[This is] a Book revealed to you, [O Muhammad], so let there be no discomfort in your chest from it..."
(Quran 7:2)
The discomfort and distress, as we have mentioned, were among the reactions that came from the people. What Noah (peace be upon him) brought in this story is guidance—clear and manifest guidance that the sound intellect accepts and the pure innate nature finds peace with, no matter how much the dust of shirk and distance from Allah has risen.
Yet, these elite said the opposite of the Prophet’s message. The message of the Prophets is clear guidance, and these elite declare him to be in clear error.
Reflect with me on these profound meanings: the accusation, the accusation that is the complete opposite of what the Prophet represents in his people and his message.
And reflect with me on his response. He said:
"O my people, there is not in me any error."
(Quran 7:61)
They accused him of clear error, but error takes many forms; not all errors are the same. This noble Prophet, Noah (peace be upon him), said:
"O my people, there is not in me any error—indeed, not even a single error."
Not only am I not in error, but his statement "there is not in me any error" negates all forms of error: ignorance, arrogance, lack of knowledge, and other different forms. Every type of error—error not of a single kind—is negated from him.
The Messenger's Task and the Art of Advice
But I am "a messenger from the Lord of the worlds." The verse here is simply the answer and the nature of the discussion that was taking place between him and his people, and between the elite. It shows us a very important truth: that when dealing with people in good, reformist projects, one must interact with them according to their actual intellectual capacity. One should not be distant from their level of understanding or even from the way they engage with their own people in terms of their intellects, concepts, and minds.
In brief words: "It is not out of misguidance, but I am a messenger from the Lord of the worlds." What is the function of the messenger? Simply, I convey to you. All messengers came with the call to convey and the mission of conveying. The message itself, in its concept and wording, is not something I have any part in. This is what this noble Prophet—and all the prophets—wanted to say. The content of the message has nothing to do with the Prophet. The conveying is "I convey to you the messages of my Lord."
But this conveying is inseparable from advice: "And I advise you, and I know from Allah what you do not know." Advice is that one seeks the best thing to present to others. And advice cannot come from someone who is not loving. Advice is an art that we often lack. I recall that one day I came across a book in English titled "The Art of Advice" (فن النصيحة), which discusses etiquette, methods, means, and what we might call the psychology of advice—understanding the psychology of the counterpart, the one I am advising, and how I can interact with them.
However, in the midst of what we are in today, advice in our time and age has become heavy on the soul; people are not drawn to it because there has been a mixing of concepts.
Here, the noble Prophet Noah, peace be upon him, clarified in this discourse with his people that his role is that of a conveyer, but this conveying is based on advice, based on loving good for them, based on loving to present to them the best that can be. And so he conveys to them and presents it to them. This is a very beautiful point in the chapter of advice—it is very important that when a person gives advice, they confirm to the other party not only with words but with actions, and they pave the way for them by showing that the primary and original motive behind that advice is love and fear. At the beginning, he said: "I fear for you the punishment of a great Day," thus giving advice.
Therefore, we need to spread these concepts and build them alongside the issues of advice and mutual advice. We need this today to renew the concepts of advice in our lives so that advice does not become a burden on the advisor or a feeling of heaviness and unacceptability from the advisee. We need to spread these concepts among ourselves. Conversely, the person being advised also needs to be humble toward the advisor.
As we discuss and reflect on these verses, let us not imagine that we are in the society of the people of Noah—this is a society, a society in which there is an advisor and there is the elite, there is a faction of the elite. This faction, as we mentioned just now, is naturally influential, empowered, and engages in distorting facts and forging them to the point that they say about the truth that it is clear misguidance. The other faction is that of the advisor, the honest advisor who wants to convey a true message, a message based on truth, not on distortion or forgery.
What is striking is that every society, ancient or modern, is never devoid of these two factions—individuals or groups. There is the faction of the elite who engage in flattery at the expense of the people's interests, the public interest, and who obstruct the path of Allah. And there is the other faction, the faction of the advisors. Why do some people not accept the advisors and instead accept these elite? Because the elite choose words, descriptions, and matters with which they distort the facts so that the truth appears other than what it is. Distortion is one of the methods of Satan. Even when Satan came to Adam, peace be upon him, and his wife, he swore to them: "Indeed, I am to you both from among the sincere advisors."
Balance between prophets' and Satan's stories
Reflect with me: we have said and reiterate many times that the proportion between the verses of the Great Book is astonishing—in word, in verse, in objectives, in everything.
At the beginning of Surah Al-A'raf, our Lord, the Exalted, spoke about Satan, saying: "And he swore to them, 'Indeed, I am to you both from among the sincere advisors.'"
Now, our Lord, the Exalted, mentions in all the stories of the prophets: "And I advise you," "an honest advisor." But the difference between what Satan claimed with his tongue of advice and what these prophets say truthfully to their people is a vast difference.
Satan merely claimed, even swore to this claim, and this is what made Adam, peace be upon him, think: if he is swearing by Allah, how can he be lying? In this way, Satan was able to achieve what he wanted. But in reality, advice is not mere claim, not just words. Not everyone who says to you, "I advise you, I am an advisor," has truly advised you. So what is the matter?
The matter is that you apply your mind to the content and substance of this message that is presented as advice. This is the key, the safety valve that truly saves a person from falling into this dangerous problem.
Many people today may claim to advise you. How do you know who truly advises you from those who do not? You look at the content of the advice, its premises, its results, and you weigh the matters. That is why he clarified that message, saying: "Do you wonder that a reminder has come to you from your Lord through a man from among you, to warn you, that you may become righteous and perhaps you will receive mercy?"
Look at this meaning that came in his message, in which his role was nothing but that of a conveyer. How does salvation come? Through righteousness, and then mercy descends: "to warn you, that you may become righteous and perhaps you will receive mercy."
And remember with me that Surah Al-A'raf is one of the surahs that pays great attention to the aspect of righteousness, and the garment of righteousness is the best. Righteousness that brings mercy to man.
Consequences of Denial
We seek nothing but the mercy of Allah, the Exalted, and we are in dire need of His mercy. Even those who disbelieve in Him and reject His signs are in need of His mercy; they are never devoid of it. However, this mercy is of a rubūbiyyah (lordly) nature, as He is the Lord of all mankind—both the disbelievers and the believers. But the ilāhiyyah (divine) mercy is a special one reserved for His servants who believe and fear Him. Thus, the outcome is clear, and let us reflect together on the verses:
"But they denied him, so We saved him and those with him in the ship, and We drowned those who denied Our signs. Indeed, they were a blind people." (Quran 7:64)
The consequence of general denial of the message is presented directly, which is perfectly suited to what the Prophet ﷺ addressed. The Prophet ﷺ lived for a long time—indeed, he passed away—without seeing the full consequences of his people’s denial. Yet here, Allah, the Exalted, presents the outcome directly. The result is decisive.
There is no person who denies the methodology of the prophets and messengers—this methodology being what Allah, the Exalted, has revealed—whose end is ever good, whether we see that end in our lifetime or not.
"But they denied him, so We saved him and those with him in the ship, and We drowned those who denied Our signs. Indeed, they were a blind people." (Quran 7:64)
In brief, they were a people blind to the truth. The facts were before their eyes, but the problem often lies not in the existence or absence of truth. The problem lies in humanity’s ability to perceive that truth or to ignore its existence. This is a grave issue.
The truth and faith in Allah, the Exalted, exist—but for whom? Who sees it? It is seen by those who have been able to perceive the truths. Those who are blind cannot see—not because they lack the faculty of perception, sight, or vision, nor because they lack the ability to see. A person may have the physical capacity to see with their eyes, but this is not enough to make the image they see in reality enter their soul and become a truth. This is the problem of denying the prophets.
Thus, our Lord, the Exalted, has said multiple times:
"But they denied [the messengers], they denied Our signs." (Quran 7:63)
Why denial and lying? Because the matter was true, real, and factual. Lying, in this context, means that a person brings forth something contrary to reality, truth, and sincerity. And this is precisely what these people did.
Perhaps some of those who followed Noah (peace be upon him) and believed in his message were poor and not from the elite. The Quran does not mention them in this verse or in this context. It only says:
"So We saved him and those with him."
But the issue is not about status or influence in society. The issue is the outcome, the consequence. What is the consequence?
"So We saved him and those with him. And We drowned those who denied Our signs."
Our fates as human beings are not tied to our status—whether social, material, political, or anything else. They are tied to our deeds, to what we produce, and to what we put forth.
"The good land yields its vegetation by permission of its Lord; but the bad yields nothing but scant growth." (Quran 7:58)
The matter is not about what Allah has granted a servant in terms of means. The important question is: what results will come from what Allah has granted? This is a profound matter regarding the proportionality in this story—the story of Noah (peace be upon him)—which Allah begins in Surah Al-A'raf. It is a story that illustrates the journey of humanity, the stages a person goes through in life, and the consequences of standing at each stage. Moreover, this swift narration in the verses also shows that life, for nations and individuals alike—no matter how long it lasts—is limited and short. The issue is not the period humans spend, but the true matter lies in the actions they perform and leave behind.