Contemplating Surah Al-A'raf: Episode 16
Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuh
In our previous session, we reflected upon Surah Al-Araf, stopping at the verse where Allah the Exalted says:
Musa (Moses) said to his people: "Seek help in Allah and be patient. Verily, the earth belongs to Allah. He gives it as a heritage to whom He wills of His slaves, and the (best) end is for the Muttaqin (the pious)."
This is a great law among the laws that govern nations and societies in their journey on earth. "The earth belongs to Allah" — it does not belong to anyone, not to any human being.
What draws attention now is that as we begin the early chapters of the story of Musa (peace be upon him) in Surah Al-Araf, it is presented in distinct episodes or battles (maqaalid), and each episode serves a purpose, contributing to the grand objective of Surah Al-Araf: to illustrate the journey of humanity, the challenges it faces in life and after death. This journey is embodied in the story of Musa (peace be upon him) with his people, serving as a living example and model.
The verse that preceded this was spoken by the elite (al-mala’) of Pharaoh’s people, who witnessed what they saw — the signs before their very eyes. They saw the sorcerers, who had been working for Pharaoh’s benefit and in service of his authority, prostrate themselves before their Creator, the Exalted. It was not merely a prostration, but a profound submission and humility before Allah the Exalted and His command. They felt that life under Pharaoh’s rule was not worth living, and that death — meeting Allah with this faith and the spiritual reservoir that had taken root in their hearts — was more honorable than anything else.
Despite all this, the elite of Pharaoh’s people did not change. The verses clearly state that they closed off all avenues of perception and feeling toward the signs, whether sensory or intellectual. Nothing could penetrate their hearts. We mentioned that the term tatbeeq (sealing) in the verse:
"Allah seals the hearts of the disbelievers."
is a form of punishment. Nothing from the promises or the impact of the signs could reach that heart. This sealing did not come without cause; it was a result of humans themselves closing off all those windows that could allow the truth and the signs of truth to enter their hearts.
The key point here is that they resolved to continue their path of oppression against the Children of Israel, a path they had followed for long periods: displacement, torture, killing — "We shall kill their sons and let live their women, and we have indeed power over them."
Oppression and humiliation — oppression is not merely physical torture. It includes the humiliation and degradation of human dignity. This is the most dangerous aspect of the issue, as we will see in its consequences later. We will discuss the situations Musa (peace be upon him) faced and his statement about oppression. There are several articles and books on this topic under the title "Psychology of Oppression." Oppression has extremely negative effects on the psyche of the oppressed and broken individual, as we will explain in its contexts.
Thus, this policy followed by the elite and Pharaoh led to any result? It led to the consequences we will examine later. But the point here is that despite all this, Musa (peace be upon him), as a prophet sent by Allah the Exalted, remained steadfast in his trust in Allah’s promise:
"The earth belongs to Allah. He gives it as a heritage to whom He wills of His slaves."
This is not a theoretical truth; it is a factual reality. Whether a person believes it or not is another matter — it depends on their certainty, understanding, and awareness of the destinies of previous nations. Surah Al-Araf has demonstrated this in more than one story, including the story of Musa (peace be upon him) in the sixth chapter of the surah. But all the stories of the prophets that preceded it in the surah have illustrated this:
"The earth was not for the people of ‘Ad, nor for the people of Nuh (Noah), nor for the people of Shu‘aib, nor for the people of Lut. For whom then? It was for Allah to give as a heritage to whom He wills of His slaves. And the (best) end is for the Muttaqin (the pious)."
We mentioned in the previous session that the Quran provides us with a space for reflection: there is faith, and there is taqwa (piety). Taqwa is a degree to which a person ascends through faith and self-struggle until they become worthy — worthy of inheriting this earth. This inheritance is not permanent; it does not last for anyone except by Allah’s command. Rather, it means establishing the law of Allah and His messages in it, as we will elaborate further.
The Stance of the Children of Israel
Children of Israel's Stance on the Word
What was the stance of the Children of Israel toward this word? This is a great word. When someone today says to you, "Seek help from Allah," what is your immediate response? You say, "Yes, and Allah’s help." But it is very clear that these people—the people of Musa—had endured years of humiliation and oppression. This made them see nothing but a bleak, deadly outlook, one in which there was no glimmer of hope for a better tomorrow, no expectation that conditions would improve beyond their current state.
They said, "We have been harmed before you came to us, and since you came to us, they have not considered anything." They did not look at any of the signs—signs that were truly capable of moving mountains from their places—tangible signs. Despite all this, the people never reflected on any of this. They only focused on a narrow point: the harm, pain, sorrows, and enslavement they had endured at the hands of Pharaoh and his elite. They did not even consider the statement made by Musa (peace be upon him).
And this matter is very important because it will come up later as we discuss the stances that Musa (peace be upon him) faced with his statement, "And we will try to understand the psychology of these people—the psychology of a people who were clearly affected by long years of enslavement and the oppression practiced by Pharaoh and his elite."
Allah says:
"It may be that your Lord will destroy your enemy and make you successors in the land, and then He will see how you will act."
Quran 7:129
And my Lord is the most knowing, and He is the best of observers. But this is the sunnah (way) of testing, the sunnah of examination. Allah knows all, but He does not judge us based on His knowledge, for He is Just. He judges and holds us accountable based on our actions, not His absolute knowledge. And He is the One who knows us best.
Then came the signs to clarify directly that after the story of the sorcerers, the process of administering punishment or indicators of punishment began for the people of Pharaoh. The punishment did not come to Pharaoh and his people all at once; it came in stages.
"And We afflicted the people of Pharaoh with years [of drought] and a deficiency in fruits that they might be reminded."
Quran 7:130
The people of Pharaoh lived in clear economic prosperity. Had it not been for this economic prosperity enjoyed by the elite of Pharaoh and the classes close to him, there would have been no political stability. The economic prosperity in the society of Pharaoh was distorted, tainted by injustice and oppression, built upon the enslavement of the Children of Israel. Society was stratified: a class of slaves, a class of masters, a class of the elite, a class of the elite close to power, and layers of authority. This stratification gnawed at society, undermining its foundations.
Allah, the Exalted, who knows His servants and this is a sunnah (way) and law of Allah, did not strike the family of Pharaoh with punishment suddenly. He gave them stages, saying:
"Perhaps they will remember."
Quran 7:131
Thus, the trials and hardships changed the conditions. Here, there was a shift in circumstances from economic prosperity to years of drought, scarcity, and a deficiency in produce—a change in the economic state, indeed.
When we witness any change in economic conditions, we can cite dozens of justifications and reasons from economic, political, and analytical perspectives for why it happened—why exports or imports declined, leading to a drop in income levels. But as the Quran teaches us, this does not contradict reflection and contemplation on what lies beyond all of this. What is beyond this? The test, the trial, so that they may remember. This change and fluctuation in the conditions of an individual, a society, or nations is for the purpose of remembrance, grace, and realization that this human being was created for a purpose. He should not worship or incline toward this world, believing that economic stability or prosperity is a permanent state in this world. The world does not remain in one state.
And contemplate with me the verse that follows:
"But when good came to them, they said, 'This is for us.' And if evil befell them, they would blame Musa and those with him. But indeed, their fortune is with Allah—but most of them do not know."
Quran 7:131
They do not know anything. They do not understand the wisdom behind the test through good and evil—through prosperity and decline, ease and hardship, ascent and descent.
This change and fluctuation in conditions should have made them realize their reality. They should have reflected on what lies beyond this change and fluctuation. Allah, the Exalted, wants you to remember. He wants you to recalculate, to reconsider. This is happening among us today—individuals and societies experience fluctuations in conditions. We do not remain in one state, and this fluctuation is the nature of this world, a world of change. And human nature is the same.
The wise person—the one whom the Quran addresses—is addressed with both sense and intellect. The Quran calls upon him to reflect and remember past days, the present, and the future, to repent, and to recalculate. He should see that the matter is not merely about numbers rising and falling. It is a matter related to one’s relationship with Allah, the Exalted. How excellent is the way to deal with it! It is a matter related to one’s inability to establish the commands of Allah within himself and his society. All of this, without a doubt, revolves around the issue of economics, as we will see in the discussions to come.
Pharaoh and His People's Stance Towards the Signs
What stance did Pharaoh and his people, or the elite of Pharaoh, adopt towards all these signs? They said, "No matter what sign you bring us to bewitch us with, we will not believe in you." This completely closed off all channels of perception and reception for them. When a person shuts their ears, eyes, and heart to reflection and contemplation of the signs and events—as will come in the verses at the end of the Surah—it is incomprehensible; they neither hear nor see. They closed everything and issued their verdict: "You are bewitching us."
In their decisions, they believed that Moses, peace be upon him, was either a prophet or a sorcerer, regardless of the accusations and falsehoods they pursued. The signs that came to them—transformations and changes—were attributed to the fact that you want to bewitch us, and we will not believe in you.
Reflecting on Their Persistence in Stance
The most dangerous thing a person, society, nation, or institution can do is persist in not revisiting themselves. A rational person reviews their calculations continuously—day by day if not hour by hour—but to leave calculations unreviewed is sheer absurdity unworthy of a human being, whom Allah has honored. These people never used their intellect at all.
Here, Allah the Exalted came to them suddenly with the greatest of signs—all sensory signs. He sent upon them floods, locusts, lice, frogs, and blood—detailed, sensory signs. The sensory signs the Quran speaks of are disasters—natural disasters. Some people today claim that the era of sensory signs has ended and the like. How so? It is true that there is no longer a staff that turns into a serpent or a hand that becomes white, but these natural disasters the Quran speaks of still exist, and they are signs. What happens in our reality and the world around us—floods, natural disasters, environmental pollution—are also signs. For what purpose? "That He may make them taste some of what they have done so that they might return." (Quran 6:165)
The question is not about the signs; the question is about the stance toward those signs. Is it to return? Is it to review and hold oneself accountable? Or is it arrogance toward those signs?
The stance of the people of Pharaoh was astonishing—they were arrogant and a criminal people. Why? The people were steeped in misguidance; their hearts, eyes, and ears were sealed, so the signs no longer affected them. They said from the beginning: "No matter what sign you bring us to bewitch us with, we will not believe in you." The most dangerous thing is for a person to decide to disbelieve, and this is the most dangerous thing. Once that decision is made of their own accord, the signs—no matter how many—will not affect them. Signs are present everywhere, at all times, in every era of our lives. A sign in the structure of our bodies, a sign in everything—"For everything there is a sign, and He is the One who manifests the signs." (Quran 41:53) But the issue is not the signs; the issue is the stance of the human being toward the signs.
What Happened Next?
Whenever these disasters and punishments afflicted them, they would turn to Moses in panic. So, deep down, they knew who had sent these signs upon them—the Lord of Moses, peace be upon him. Thus, they knew the stance: denial and rejection of the truth. They could not, no matter how hard they tried, obscure its traces. They said, "O Moses, invoke your Lord for us as He has promised you. If you remove the punishment from us, we will surely believe in you and send the Children of Israel with you." (Quran 7:134)
So when We removed the punishment from them for a term they were to fulfill, behold! They broke their word. The Great Quran had already stated: "We found no faith in most of them, but most of them were defiantly disobedient." (Quran 7:139)
This is a nature not found in every human being—the nature of the obstinate, arrogant, and ungrateful person. Whenever a sign came to them, they would say, "I will believe," but when they returned to their previous state of stability, blessings, health, and strength, they reverted to their old ways.
What Was the Final Outcome?
We took retribution from them—the final punishment—so We drowned them in the sea. Reflect with me on the end of the verse: "Because they denied Our signs and were heedless of them." (Quran 7:136) Reflect with me on the description of the state and the cause: denial of the signs of Allah the Exalted, whether they were the sensory signs they had seen many of or the signs they see in their lives and reality. The outcome is the same: denial. The reason for the denial is not that they did not believe in the signs; the reason for the denial is heedlessness.
The people of Pharaoh and the elite had something between them and seeing the consequences of those signs—it was the thing called authority, influence, power, and arrogance. The feeling of false, empty pride made them heedless of the most prominent and important truth. Instead, they busied themselves talking about Moses, peace be upon him, and his state, and how Moses would do this and that, and drive us out of our land. Deliver the message! When a message comes to you—and this message is clear from the Lord of the Worlds, Exalted is He—look into the message, its essence, its content, and its details. If you turn and twist it to revolve around another issue outside the message, this will not lead to any result. This is what happened.
Heedlessness is the most dangerous disease afflicting societies and nations. Heedlessness can be complete, so that no sign affects the person no matter what they go through. It can also be partial. Partial heedlessness can be treated through remembrance, returning to the Book of Allah, seeking forgiveness, doing good deeds, and having a companion who advises and reminds—all these things can help a person emerge from temporary heedlessness, so to speak. But the problem lies in permanent, persistent heedlessness. If temporary heedlessness is not treated, it becomes permanent, and then this is the end described by the Quran: a person who is not affected by anything; the signs do not affect him.
This was the painful end of Pharaoh and his people—an end that could befall any nation or society that denies and disbelieves in the signs of Allah, Exalted is He. However, it is not necessary that the destruction be total; it could be partial, where only some of the people are destroyed, and others are left. Allah, Exalted is He, turns away His servants as He wills and sends down punishment and signs as He wills. But as we read the Quran, reflect, ponder, and look into the destinies of nations and peoples...
The Promise to the People of Moses
The verses then transition to the promise that Allah, the Exalted, made to the people of Moses through their prophet, peace be upon him. He said:
"And We caused the people who had been oppressed to inherit the eastern regions and the western ones which We had blessed." (Quran 7:137)
Just a few verses earlier, it was stated:
"Did your Lord not promise you a goodly promise?" (Quran 20:86)
Now, the promise has been fulfilled. What draws attention in this verse is the word "oppressed" (المستضعفين), as it is a key term in our reflection upon the Book of Allah. The verse does not specify that these were the people who believed in Moses; rather, it highlights only one characteristic of the people of Moses in this context. Thus, this word is central to the story of Moses, peace be upon him, and pivotal in all the stages and stories that follow regarding Moses and his people’s trials with him.
"They were oppressed" (يستضعفون) is the most prominent trait of the people of Moses. They were oppressed by Pharaoh, living under his whip, humiliation, and subjugation. This is a long-standing, critical issue that we will address in detail, exploring its implications and effects. When the Quran reminds us of a specific word or matter, it intends for us to move from that story to the reality in which we live, so that we may learn from the mistakes of previous nations, societies, and individuals in their dealings with their families and communities—something we will explore further.
Many contemporary and classical commentators, when encountering this word, say: "Yes, reflect and ponder over the wisdom of Allah, the Almighty, in how He made these oppressed people kings and rulers." This is one aspect of the story, but there are other dimensions and deeper meanings that we must reflect upon and pause at for a long time. We need to examine all the situations that the people of Moses faced in Surah Al-A'raf and reflect deeply on this word:
"And We caused the people who had been oppressed to inherit the eastern regions and the western ones which We had blessed. And the fair promise of your Lord was fulfilled for the Children of Israel because they were patient." (Quran 7:137)
The patience mentioned here is not the passive patience that implies inaction or failure to strive for change or improvement in one's reality or life. Rather, the wisdom of Allah in this verse is to present us with a different model from those in the stories of all the prophets mentioned before. The story of Moses and his people differs from the stories of all other prophets. After Allah saved Moses and the believers with him, the Quran does not mention details about their lives afterward—nothing is said about their future. But in the story of Moses, the narrative begins after the salvation of his people from Pharaoh. All the lessons, warnings, and reflections the Quran conveys seem like new stories and new situations because we need them in our lives. For every nation, past and present, must internalize these lessons in its memory and reality.
The Israelites are a nation of the past, yet they remain a living nation today, extending through history. This history and these events are worthy of study, with attentive ears and hearts that grasp the lessons and promises within them.
Indeed, the issue of Pharaoh was destroyed; Pharaoh, who was seen by the Children of Israel as the tyrannical oppressor who stood between them and all good, is gone—never to return. So, one might expect that, now that the obstacle preventing them from fulfilling their mission is gone, the believers in Allah, the Almighty, would realize that human responsibility on Earth is not merely about the existence of Pharaoh or anyone else. You are required to fulfill your duty, to do good, to build the Earth, and to forbid corruption, whether the oppressor is Pharaoh or someone else. Now that Pharaoh is gone, what will you do? How will you act? What is the nature of the task you are to undertake on Earth? The obstacles and barriers that may have hindered you from achieving your goals have been removed. The field is now yours, O Children of Israel. And your Lord, the All-Knowing, is watching how you will act.
Children of Israel After Victory
First Story After Conquest and Victory
The first direct story after this conquest and divine victory is the story of the first stance mentioned: "And We took the Children of Israel across the sea" [Quran 2:50]. They did not cross it on foot; they did not walk upon it with their own feet. The sea itself was not a path they traversed nor did they cross it with their own legs. Who was it that carried them across? It was our Lord, the Exalted, who said, "And We took them across."
Contemplate the wording in the Book of Allah, the Mighty and Majestic, where He made that sea dry land so that the Children of Israel could walk upon it. The Lord, the Able, the Exalted, says to a thing, "Be," and it is. He made the sea drown Pharaoh and his hosts and made that same sea solid ground, a suitable land for the Children of Israel to walk upon. The Lord, the Exalted, is capable of all things.
This miracle alone should have been sufficient to stir within them all the promises of warning and admonition. But what happened? "And We took the Children of Israel across the sea." The first thing they saw upon crossing was a people devoted to idols of Allah. It is natural—after all they had witnessed of miracles and tangible signs before their very eyes—that if tangible miracles and signs were sufficient to move the heart of man towards faith and monotheism, then it was expected that the Children of Israel, upon seeing these people worshipping idols of stone and statues, worshipping other than Allah, would have the rational among them—who had seen with their own eyes the miracles and signs of Allah, the Exalted—warn them, correct the error, rectify the corruption, and halt the polytheism they were witnessing.
The stance of this nation, as the Great Quran informs us, was the opposite. Instead of correcting the corruption they saw before them and the polytheism they witnessed, they said, "O Moses, make for us a god just as they have gods" [Quran 7:138]. A request that is extremely strange, extremely astonishing.
How could these people ask for gods of idols to draw near to their Creator? They did not ask to worship these idols instead of Allah; rather, they asked for these idols to mediate between themselves and Allah. They still had not realized, after all these signs, that there is no intermediary between the servant and his Lord. These idols neither benefit nor harm, and the Lord whom you worship—you must purify your monotheism in your heart and soul and turn to Him directly. If you desire something, you ask Him directly without an intermediary—whether that intermediary is a human or a stone.
How is it that they had not yet realized this truth? And why?
The magicians of Pharaoh realized it—the magicians who performed magic for Pharaoh and witnessed the signs of Musa (peace be upon him)—but these people did not. Why did the magicians realize it, and why did the people of Musa not?
The Quran tells us in Surah Ghafir (40:28):
"And a believing man from the family of Pharaoh who concealed his faith said, 'Do you kill a man [merely] because he says, "My Lord is Allah," while he has brought you clear proofs from your Lord? And if he is a liar, then upon him is [the consequence of] his lie; but if he is truthful, there will strike you some of what he promises you. Indeed, Allah does not guide one who is a transgressor and a liar.'"
What made this believing man, who concealed his faith, see what the people of Musa did not see? What made the magicians of Pharaoh undergo this astonishing transformation—from a type of disbelief to faith—while the people of Musa did not undergo a similar transformation but rather the opposite?
There is no doubt that this issue has many dimensions and profound effects, which will gradually become clear in the various stances of the Surah.
Musa's People: Exodus and Causes
The people of Musa left with Musa (peace be upon him) for what purpose? To escape the oppression of Pharaoh—his humiliation of their women and the killing of their sons. From oppression, tyranny, and enslavement. But pure faith and monotheism did not permeate their hearts. What was the reason, then?
Perhaps the reasons are varied, but one of the most prominent factors that the Quran mentions in this context is that they were oppressed. When a human being is oppressed for a long period and subjected to coercion, very serious problems arise if they do not become aware of them. One of these problems is that, over time, they begin to believe—day after day, hour after hour, generation after generation—that this tyrant, this oppressor represented by Pharaoh, possesses a power other than Allah. He has power; he has might, as evidenced by his ability to inflict punishment upon them.
Gradually, they become accustomed to this type of enslavement and subjugation, until it becomes the norm in their lives. They are struck, humiliated, slapped, and silenced out of fear of Pharaoh and his hosts. When this practice becomes a daily occurrence in their lives, it leads to the threatening of monotheism and its undermining.
How does this happen? The thread of monotheism is delicate; it can unravel thread by thread through these practices. How? By making them feel that the process of seeking sustenance is an ordinary matter compared to the food they ate—the lentils, onions, and garlic mentioned in Surah Al-Baqarah (2:61).
The people of Musa longed for the days of Pharaoh. Other surahs mention this so that we may understand, as we reflect upon the verses in Surah Al-A'raf (7:137-138), why the people of Musa committed this disgraceful act and made this strange request immediately after being freed from Pharaoh's authority.
To understand this, we must delve into the psychology of these people. And to understand their psychology, we must read the verses in the surahs that mention the story of the people of Musa with Pharaoh and Musa (peace be upon him). They made this request, and they will make it again. Surah Al-A'raf may not mention this specific request, but Surah Al-Baqarah does (2:61):
"Do you exchange what is better for what is worse? And [why do you] not go out from the land?"
Did they feel nostalgia for the food they ate when they were oppressed slaves, subdued by Pharaoh and his hosts? Did they feel nostalgia for the food but not for the meaning of honor and freedom? Were they willing to return to the days of slavery merely to eat lentils, onions, and garlic? Did they not desire to taste the sweetness of freedom and liberation from Pharaoh's tyranny and oppression?
Musa (peace be upon him) said to his people, "Thus are the people—possessing many problems indeed."
The Quran, in Surah Al-A'raf, presents these problems to us. Why does it present them? To make us reflect upon them, to realize that one of the most prominent issues arising from tyranny, misguidance, and human subjugation is the destruction of beautiful meanings in the souls—meanings such as monotheism.
Monotheism is not merely a word; it is to believe in Allah as the One, the Able, the Unique, with no partner in dominion, no equal, the Self-Sufficient, the Strong, the One who is above His servants. When you see a human being like Pharaoh attempting to claim or make others believe that he possesses any of the attributes of Lordship, you must recognize the extent of his tyranny, oppression, and arrogance. You must reject this more strongly, preserving within your heart the meanings of monotheism and faith in Allah's names and attributes.
This is why the magicians, when they said to Pharaoh, "No harm upon us; indeed, we are to our Lord returning" [Quran 26:50], did not cease Pharaoh's oppression nor escape his tyranny. Pharaoh said to them, "I will surely cut off your hands and feet on opposite sides, and I will surely crucify you all" [Quran 26:49]. But what did the magicians say? "No harm."
Why? Because the magicians had knowledge. They fully realized and firmly believed at that moment of truth—when Pharaoh's tyranny and oppression were at their peak—that all the power and might Pharaoh possessed were false and illusory. They stood before nothing compared to the true power of Allah, the Exalted.
"We have believed in the Lord of Musa and Harun. The Lord of the worlds is the Lord of Musa and Harun." [Quran 26:47-48]
This was a moment of truth. The people of Musa, however, had not yet reached this point.
The Psychology of Enslavement
It is worth mentioning in this context that there are books and articles written on the psychology of enslavement and the dangers of this psychology. When a human being is enslaved, subjected to various forms of torture, humiliation, degradation, and mockery over extended periods, his humanity is broken. He is humiliated, yet Allah, the Exalted, created him with honor, dignity, and nobility. If he does not overcome this trial and realize that freedom and human dignity are inherent in his creation—bestowed by the One, the Unique Creator, and not by any human being—then, over time, he becomes a sick individual. The issue of enslavement and exploitation becomes normal to him, and in some cases, it becomes a disease.
If such a person is not subjected to degradation and humiliation, he feels as though he is losing something—real pathological conditions. This is what is known as the psychology of enslavement.
The Stanford Prison Experiment
What truly caught my attention is that in 1971, a professor at Stanford University in the United States conducted an experiment. He divided a group of his students into two roles: one group would act as prisoners, and the other as guards. The experiment was supposed to last two weeks, but the professor could not complete it beyond six days because the results exceeded all expectations.
A large number of the "prisoners"—originally healthy students with sound mental and psychological faculties—collapsed. They experienced real breakdowns due to the humiliation, degradation, and terror they were subjected to. The results also affected the "guards"—the students who played the role of oppressors. Despite the short duration of only six days, some of them began to enjoy the exercise of power. Initially, they felt uncomfortable with violence, but over time, they became accustomed to it and even took pleasure in it.
This is a very serious issue. Here, we understand one of the greatest wisdoms and reasons why the story of Musa (peace be upon him) is present in many surahs of the Quran. Musa is the prophet most frequently mentioned in the Book of Allah. Why is the story of Musa and his people a story worthy of contemplation? It is the story of peoples—peoples of the earth, past, present, and future—a story that should evoke many meanings within us.
The Dangers of Breaking a Child's Spirit
Therefore, one of the most dangerous things in education is when some parents, mothers, educators, or teachers—intentionally or unintentionally—resort to humiliating a child and breaking their spirit. This is extremely dangerous.
You will see that when you strike or slap a child, for example, they cry bitterly—especially the first time. But if this becomes a repeated practice over time, the child may eventually laugh it off. This is a real psychological disorder.
But the first time a child is slapped, why do they cry bitterly? It is not just because of the physical pain of the slap; it is the psychological pain that accompanies it—the breaking of their self and their humanity.
Allah, the Exalted, created humans free and honorable. The freedom and human dignity that Allah has granted to humans are not related to their color, gender, wealth, lineage, family, or companionship. From the moment Allah created humans, He said, "And We have certainly honored the children of Adam" [Quran 17:70]. He created them with honor, and they sense this honor within themselves.
If humans are then subjected to practices—whether by educators, some parents, or others—that begin to break this humanity and dignity, step by step, the danger lies in how this broken psyche can be rebuilt. How can something broken in the human psyche be reconstructed and repaired? This is a very dangerous process.
Here, we are faced with a people whose psyches were broken—broken by the practices of Pharaoh: his coercion, his tyranny, his oppression, his humiliation, his killing, his fear, his displacement from their homes and dwellings, his threats, and his enslavement. They were enslaved to Pharaoh, forced to fulfill his desires. Could all this not have an effect?
Of course, it did. What was the result?
Musa (peace be upon him) said to his people:
"Indeed, you are a people behaving ignorantly" [Quran 2:67].
The word "ignorant" here is a profound pause. Ignorance is the deadliest enemy of monotheism and faith—in all its forms and manifestations. "You are ignorant"—ignorant of what? Of the fact that Pharaoh said, "I do not know that you have any god other than me" [Quran 28:38], but the effects of Pharaoh did not depart with him. The effects of Pharaoh remained in the souls of the Children of Israel.
Pharaoh departed, but his legacy did not. Pharaoh departed, but the ignorance he planted in the souls of the Children of Israel did not depart. Pharaoh departed with his tyranny, but the effects of that tyranny remained embedded in their psyches.
The Danger of Tyranny
The danger of tyranny is immense—tyranny in all its forms. Tyranny is not merely political or governmental; it includes familial tyranny, social tyranny, and educational tyranny. We will pause to reflect on educational tyranny and its dangers.
And we will pause to reflect on tyranny.
Types of Tyranny
Tyranny of Thought, Opinion, Information, Authority, and Society
Tyranny occurs when there is tyranny of thought, tyranny of opinion, tyranny of information, tyranny of authority, and tyranny of society. When tyranny is exercised within the household, it begins with the smallest member—the child. From the moment a child is born, they are not allowed to express their opinion freely, are not permitted to say "no," and are not involved in decisions that concern them. All of this is the beginning of tyranny. The child gradually becomes accustomed to being a follower rather than a leader, to only listening without speaking, to only obeying without choosing, to only complying without objecting, to only executing without suggesting, and to only remaining silent without speaking. These practices are repeated over long periods, turning the child into a person with no value, no opinion, and no counsel—a dehumanized individual stripped of their essence.
The cause of this is the incorrect upbringing adopted by some parents. From here, we understand the gravity of tyranny—not just political tyranny, but the tyranny practiced within the walls of the home, which has devastating negative effects on the psychology of children. In the end, this produces a distorted generation, one that is ready to accept any opinion, any thought, any culture, or any direction, simply doing what is asked of them without the slightest thought, consideration, or review. They do not critique, they do not think, they do not express an opinion—and the reason is the upbringing they received.
The problem is that these psychological ailments arising from familial tyranny are transmitted and spread to society. The society then becomes tyrannical, where one group tyrannizes another, the rich tyrannize the poor, and the strong tyrannize the weak. The cycle continues, resulting in a sick and internally defeated society—psychologically and spiritually. What is even more dangerous is that, as we mentioned earlier, people eventually come to believe that this is the natural order or the will of God, and that it cannot be changed. "I was created to be oppressed," they think. "I was created to be humiliated. I was created to be poor. I have no ambition, no hope, and no desire to change my reality." Why? Because they were raised on submission and surrender. And what is the cause? Tyranny.
This is one of the greatest lessons we can draw from Surah Al-A'raf and the story of Prophet Musa (peace be upon him), which teaches us that tyranny in any form must not be accepted or practiced. Do not practice it within your home—with your spouse, your children, or those around you. Do not practice it at work, in your environment, in your small community, or in your larger society. If you see tyranny being practiced, strive with all your might to prevent it, resist it, and rectify it—within yourself and within others.
Reflecting on the Verse from Surah Al-Imran
Consider the words of Allah the Exalted in Surah Al-Imran (3:123):
"And Allah had already given you victory at [the battle of] Badr while you were weak."
The word "adhilah" (أذلة) here denotes a state similar to istid'af (استضعاف, oppression/weakness), but even more severe. Dhillah (ذل) is harsher than istid'af. Allah granted you victory while you were in a state of adhilah—meaning, at your weakest point. After this great victory, what should have happened? The souls of the Muslims should have changed. They should have transformed from a people of weakness to a people of strength in Allah, able to speak the truth before any oppressive ruler without fearing the blame of any critic. This is the issue that we must deeply reflect upon and ponder.
Why? Because this pattern repeats in every time and place. There are oppressed individuals living in a state of adhilah (weakness) who, when Allah grants them power in the land, mistakenly believe that empowerment (tamkin) is the ultimate goal. But empowerment is not the goal—it is a means to a greater end: elevating the word of Allah on Earth, establishing His law, spreading goodness, virtue, justice, and excellence. True empowerment and elevation of Allah’s word come through a transformation in the souls, hearts, minds, values, principles, goals, practices, and behaviors of people. This is the core issue we must focus on in the lessons derived from the story of Prophet Musa (peace be upon him) in Surah Al-A'raf.
The Consequences of Tyranny
Tyranny does what? It kills ambition. It kills willpower. It kills change. It turns humans into submissive, obedient beings—and worse, it makes them justify all the injustice and oppression around them, simply to maintain their own safety and peace. They believe that as long as they stay out of the circle of evil, they are safe.
But this is a dangerous delusion. When evil spreads and becomes widespread, it will not spare anyone. Allah the Exalted says:
"And fear a trial which will not strike those who have wronged among you exclusively." [Quran 8:25]
This trial afflicts everyone—it does not exempt the oppressor or the oppressed. Therefore, the issue is not merely staying away from the circle of injustice. The issue is striving with all your might to change that injustice and transform it into justice.
Magicians vs. Moses' People
This is what the magicians did, and this is what the people of Moses, unfortunately, did not do. The magicians were part of Pharaoh's system; they were part of Pharaoh's regime. They worked for Pharaoh, executed his orders, and were part of his tyranny. However, at a certain moment, when the message of truth, the message of monotheism, and the message of faith reached them, they did not hesitate for a single moment to change their positions, alter their loyalties, and transform from people working for falsehood to people working for the truth. Unfortunately, this did not happen with the people of Moses, who believed that their mission in life was fulfilled simply by escaping Pharaoh's grasp—a grave misconception.
He said, "Indeed, you are a people behaving ignorantly." Here, the Almighty Allah affirms in these verses that the true transformation He desired for the people of Moses had not yet occurred. Why? Because they are still ignorant of what is required of them. They are ignorant of the purpose for which they were created. They are ignorant of the task they should perform in life. They are ignorant of the reality of this world and the Hereafter. They are ignorant of the reality of Allah, the Exalted, His attributes, and His names. They are ignorant of almost everything. Thus, they are in a state of loss, confusion, and lack of clarity in vision, which led them to commit the errors that we will soon see in the context of the surah. When Allah, the Exalted, mentioned this to us, He wanted us to learn from their mistakes and avoid them.
Here, ignorance is not the absolute lack of knowledge. They are not ignorant in the sense that they know nothing at all. Rather, they know some things but are ignorant of many truths they should know. Among these truths, foremost are the reality of Allah, the Exalted, His attributes, and His names, as well as the purpose for which they were created and the task they should perform in life. These are the truths they were ignorant of, placing them in a state of loss, confusion, and lack of clarity in vision.
Then He said, "Do you exchange that which is lower for that which is better?" This is an example of their ignorance. Do you exchange freedom for servitude? Do you exchange honor for humiliation? Do you exchange dignity for disgrace? Do you exchange all these great values for cheap, trivial, and worthless ones? This was the ignorance afflicting the people of Moses, leading them to commit the errors mentioned in the context of the surah.
"Do you exchange that which is lower for that which is better? Go down to Egypt, for you will have what you have asked for." It is as if Moses, peace be upon him, is saying to them, "If you insist on these cheap, trivial values, then there is no place for you with me, nor is there a place for you in the society I seek to build." Go down to Egypt and seek these cheap, trivial values elsewhere, but they have no place here in the society I seek to build upon great values and noble principles.
This is a profound lesson we should learn from Surah Al-A'raf: that ignorance is the root of all evil, the cause of all misguidance, the cause of all confusion, and the cause of all loss. Therefore, we must strive with all our might to combat ignorance in all its forms and types. We must strive to spread knowledge and awareness through all means. We must be diligent in educating ourselves, our children, and everyone around us. We must strive to disseminate knowledge everywhere and combat ignorance through all means. We must strive to guide people to the path of truth and remind them of Allah, the Exalted, His attributes, His names, and His actions. We must remind them of the purpose for which they were created and the task they should perform in life.
This is the only path to salvation, the only path to happiness, the only path to success in this world and the Hereafter. This is the only path to building a strong, cohesive society capable of facing challenges, achieving goals, and attaining happiness, prosperity, and flourishing.
I ask Allah, the Exalted, to make us among those who listen to speech and follow the best of it. I ask Him to guide us to the straight path. I ask Him to make us among His righteous servants. I ask Him to grant us success in what He loves and is pleased with. I ask Him to make us among those who support His religion, exalt His word, and make us among those who strive on earth with righteousness and do not follow the path of the corruptors.
May Allah send His blessings and peace upon our master Muhammad, his family, and all his companions. And peace be upon you, and the mercy of Allah, and His blessings.