Reflecting on Surah Al-A'raf: Part Eleven
Lot's People: Sin of Homosexuality
In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. All praise is for Allah, the praise of those who are grateful. May the peace and blessings of Allah be upon the Master of all prophets and messengers, and upon his family and all his companions. Peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you.
In our previous session, we reflected upon the story of the people of Lot in Surah Al-A'raf. This is the only story in Surah Al-A'raf that does not begin with the stories of the prophets mentioned therein, nor does it begin with the call to monotheism. Instead, it begins with the words of Allah the Exalted:
"And [mention] Lot, when he said to his people, 'Do you commit immorality [an-fāḥishah] that no one has preceded you with from among the worlds?'" (Quran 7:80)
He did not say to them, "Worship Allah; you have no deity other than Him." Indeed, in other verses where the story of the people of Lot is mentioned—such as in Surah Ash-Shu'ara and other chapters—the Quran states that when Allah sent down punishment upon them, He said:
"And We found not within them other than a [single] house of Muslims." (Quran 51:36)
The house of Lot, peace be upon him, indicating clearly that the people were in polytheism and worshipped idols. However, the verses in Surah Al-A'raf do not mention the issue of monotheism in the story of the people of Lot. Instead, they focus on the issue of immorality, seeking refuge in Allah, and the widespread sexual perversion and deviation that had taken hold among the people.
Here, many commentators—especially contemporary ones—have differed regarding the reason behind the omission of the issue of monotheism in Surah Al-A'raf in the story of the people of Lot. The truth is, if we wish to understand the meaning and its appropriateness, we must recognize that the issue of monotheism is present, as we have mentioned, in all the stories of the prophets—a central issue. In our previous discussion, we noted that the monotheism presented in the Surah—and in the Quran as a whole—is not a theoretical monotheism detached from addressing the realities of life with its problems and crises. Rather, it is a monotheism that calls humanity to action, awakens the innate nature (fitrah) of people, and motivates them to rise and perform righteous deeds.
There is a clear connection between monotheism and its fruits: monotheism leads to righteous action, while corruption leads to evil on Earth. Undoubtedly, this heinous crime and deviation committed by the people of Lot—unprecedented among any of the worlds—were pioneers in this matter. They were the first to initiate and innovate in this abhorrent, unnatural sin that contradicts human nature (fitrah).
Connecting Quranic Verses to Real Life
Perhaps—and Allah knows best—the reason for beginning with the mention of this sin is to address a severe and real depletion of the fundamental elements of human nature (fitrah). It would be unreasonable, given that the Quran is the speech of Allah addressing the reality of humanity, for the Lord of the worlds—Who is the Most Subtle, the All-Aware, and the Knower of the innermost secrets of the soul—to address different nations and speak to us in a way that does not align with human nature and what is beneficial for it. When and how should He address them with these words? Allah, the Most Subtle, the All-Aware, the All-Knowing.
Therefore, it was entirely appropriate that the first thing Prophet Lot, peace be upon him, addressed in his call was to stop this severe hemorrhage: sexual perversion, seeking refuge in Allah, and this deviation that had afflicted the people—a severe depletion of all meanings of human nature (fitrah). It was necessary to halt this first, especially since this sin had not appeared in any previous nation. They had innovated it themselves, following the whispers of the devils, and they were the ones who initiated this abomination and perfected this form of corruption that had not existed before.
Thus, it was necessary first to stop this sin. Only after their response could other issues—such as the issue of monotheism—be addressed. However, souls that had immersed themselves entirely in the mire of this sin could never be addressed initially with matters related to a person's creed, faith, and relationship with Allah the Exalted after such a severe corruption of their innate nature.
Hence, the Quran says:
"Do you commit immorality [an-fāḥishah] that no one has preceded you with from among the worlds?" (Quran 7:80)
With the magnificent style of the Quran, the problem was truly identified in a manner that is both refined and uses words perfectly suited to the situation without violating human dignity—a Quranic demand and an important objective.
What was the response of his people? A very strange response that the Quran presents to show us that reformist projects, including the calls of the prophets, are met with baseless accusations—accusations that are almost devoid of substance yet become a reality. Why? Because the opposing side facing these projects—including, as we have mentioned, the calls of the prophets—holds influence, power in society, and control.
"And the answer of his people was not but that they said, 'Expel them from your city! Indeed, they are men who keep themselves pure.'" (Quran 7:82)
Purity, chastity, integrity, and adherence to human nature (fitrah) became a crime in their eyes, deserving of exile, banishment, and removal from the town or village. Reflect with me on these meanings—a very profound concept.
Truth vs Falsehood: Weakness and Strength
And because the Quran, as is its habit, presents matters as they truly are—truths—it states the words exactly as they were spoken by these people without any distortion or embellishment, as the devils among the jinn and mankind do. The devils among the jinn and mankind would never today say (as they did in the past): "Drive them out of your town. Indeed, they are people who keep themselves pure!" (Quran 7:82). We know that what humanity is afflicted with today—despite its pinnacle of material and technological civilization—is this degrading and shameful trial: the trial of sexual perversion. In fact, various organizations have had this heinous crime imposed upon them, meaning these organizations now wield significant and influential voices that impose their agenda of promoting this abhorrent vice within different societies.
These people of perversion now have rights that are defended, and the issue has been framed as one of personal freedom. Indeed, some heads of Arab states and U.S. presidents, in their competitive races for presidency and elections, are seen vying with one another in attempts to appease these people by pledging to defend their rights. The matter is presented as a human rights issue, a question of freedom—personal freedom and equality—and so on.
How have this small group of people managed to alter the values of the global human society, transforming their perversion, deviation, crime, and regression from human nature into an accepted reality that is defended and granted rights? When they demand their rights, they certainly do not use the phrase: "Drive them out!" or "Drive out all those who oppose this heinous crime from your town, from your homes (Indeed, they are people who keep themselves pure!)" They will not say such words. Instead, they use different language. What is it? They claim that those who stand against them do not respect human rights. Any individual, organization, or institution that opposes these deviants and those who promote this crime will be pointed out as people who do not recognize human rights and do not work to protect them, as if their cause were a legitimate right. They will not use this Quranic term ("people who keep themselves pure"), and the Quran presents realities as they are.
Why do they not use this term? The nature of the devils among the jinn and mankind, as we mentioned at the beginning of Surah Al-A'raf, is that the devil did not say to Adam, peace be upon him, and his wife: "O Adam, if you eat from this tree, you will be expelled from Paradise." Had he spoken the truth, Adam would not have eaten from it, and humanity would never have approached it. What caused Adam, peace be upon him, to fall into such temptation? It was the devil’s deception, embellishment, and cunning. How? By presenting things contrary to their true nature. Likewise, these people do not say that the reason their opponents oppose them is because of purity, natural disposition, and the preservation of human nature—regardless of the religion of the person defending this cause. No, instead, they claim that their opponents do not respect human rights, and therefore, the world must stand against them.
This is what we are experiencing today in our human societies. By the way, different societies in Europe—I am speaking specifically about Europe—have held massive demonstrations against the recognition of what they call "marriage between homosexuals." Even in their choice of words, they seek to insert the term "marriage," which is a legitimate contract recognized by all human societies in its known, respected form that befits human dignity, regardless of one’s creed or religion. They want to introduce this clean, honorable term into this heinous crime. Why? To gradually lend it a veneer of legitimacy until the point where some churches in many European countries now recognize this marriage and even officiate it. This is an open and blatant challenge to religious and human values.
The question that arises is: Why? Why this expansion and infiltration of a crime that is itself a violation of human nature? And those who engage in it should seek treatment, not promotion of their crime, corruption, and deviation. This is deviation. What is the cause of all this? The cause, as we have mentioned repeatedly, is this regression. Corruption, by its nature, does not remain confined to its place; it expands and spreads. It stops at nothing except one thing: that it be prohibited, confronted, and opposed with goodness, reform, and justice. That is why the command to enjoin good and forbid evil is one of the greatest symbols of this great religion. And this is not only in our religion but, in general, for all legitimate matters—no matter how legitimate they may be—if Allah, the Exalted, does not awaken people to defend and protect them, they will never emerge. Corruption then spreads and expands.
The issue is not one of personal freedom. Today, if you remain silent about all these transgressions in your family, your society, and your environment—without having a true voice as a human being with the humanity to reject these matters—you will reach a time when your young children will have no place to learn except among these deviants. What will you do? What will you do? How will you explain this crime to your children and little ones? How? How can humans truly remain dignified and honorable in an atmosphere where this vice and this heinous crime are practiced?
Therefore, after all these meanings, we can understand why the call did not begin with the call to monotheism. It was necessary to stop the bleeding—the severe hemorrhage in the human nature that was already present and deeply rooted in the society of the people of Lut, peace be upon him.
Why Did the Call Not Begin with Monotheism?
And for this reason, the verses do not prolong the discussion. It says: "But We saved him and his family, except his wife; she was of those who remained behind." (Quran 7:83). "And We rained upon them a rain [of stones]. Then see how was the end of the criminals." (Quran 7:84).
And reflect with me on their description with two terms: "Musrifun" (the transgressors) and "Al-Mujrimin" (the criminals). What do these two descriptions indicate in this context? They indicate the magnitude of this crime.
Extravagance and Crime in the People of Lot
Extravagance—indeed, some exegetes and scholars have stated that it refers to excess in forbidden things, while others have said it can also include excess in permissible matters. The reality is that, in this context, the word extravagance and its description, as well as the characterization of these people as extravagant, indicates something profound. It signifies the heinousness of this grave sin and reveals that this is an affliction that must be confronted within society.
Lot, peace be upon him, was alone. He was a messenger, yes, but he had no supporters around him. Reflect with me on these meanings: he faced a flood of corruption in his village, and he alone stood against these people. This does not matter. It teaches us a principle in life: when a person is truly certain that he is upon goodness, righteousness, and faith, and that he possesses a beneficial reformist project, he must stand against corruption. He must present that project, regardless of whether few or none stand with him, or whether the opposing side—defending that crime—is large in number.
We have said repeatedly that the multitude of people performing an action does not grant it legitimacy. A thing is permissible because Allah has permitted it, and it is forbidden because Allah has forbidden it. My Lord, the Exalted, in Surah Al-A'raf, recently addressed the people, saying:
"My Lord has forbidden immoral sins, both what is apparent and what is hidden." (7:33)
This is among the greatest of immoral sins. Indeed, these sins were committed in various societies, and those who engaged in them were often the majority. Yet, majority does not confer legitimacy upon anything. This is what the Quran teaches us: the Quran instructs us that truth is truth, and falsehood is falsehood—not by quantity, nor by scarcity, but by the principle itself. It acquires legitimacy from within itself, and the source of legitimacy is known: what Allah, the Exalted, has legislated.
Reflect with me on this profound meaning, which, unfortunately, is absent from the calculations of many people today. Thus, even a small handful of deviant or corrupt individuals has become capable of controlling the destinies of entire human societies.
Reflect with me on this meaning. In other words, if we were to calculate the actual proportion of deviants and corrupt individuals in various societies, we would find it to be very small compared to all those who never deviate from their innate nature (fitrah). This is not merely a matter of religion—it is about fitrah (innate human nature). Yet, despite this, we find that this small group has a loud voice. Their voice has become thunderous across the horizons, imposing their agenda upon societies, states, and organizations.
How? Through the weakness of the people of truth, the weakness of those with sound fitrah. The voices of the people of sound fitrah have become faint, while the people of truth, due to the intensity of their state—psychological, material, and media-related weakness—have become as if they are in the wrong. Meanwhile, the people of falsehood, due to the strength of their influence, power, and tyranny, have become as if they are in the right.
Truth and Falsehood: Quantity Does Not Legitimize
Thus, the Quran clarifies to me in the story of Lot, peace be upon him, the contrast between quantity, power, and influence on one side, and scarcity and weakness on the other. This is also evident in other surahs where Lot, peace be upon him, says:
"If only I had strength!" (11:80)
He had no human strength. Yet, weakness and scarcity do not mean that a person should change his principles, nor do they alter the reality of things. Truth remains truth, and falsehood remains falsehood, whether or not there are those who defend or promote it.