Contemplating Surah Al-Ghashiyah: Episode 6 {Verses 22 - 26}
Remembrance and the Role of the Prophet ﷺ
In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. All praise is due to Allah, the praise of those who are grateful. May peace and blessings be upon the leader of all prophets and messengers, and upon his family and all his companions. Peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you.
We have reached the end of the great Surah Al-Ghashiyah, those endings that are clearly and distinctly linked to the introduction: "Has there come to you the narration of the Overwhelming [event]?" This narration, by its nature, importance, themes, and intricacies, requires that human beings be reminded of it, no matter how significant it may be. The need for remembrance of this great matter is always firm and enduring; it never fades away. No matter how much knowledge a person may possess or how elevated their status, they cannot rise above this issue: remembrance.
The role of the Prophet ﷺ and his family (peace be upon them)—and let us clarify that this is not solely the role of the prophets, nor is the duty of reminding merely the role of prophets and messengers—rather, it is also the role of the teacher, the educator, the mother, the father, the uncle, the aunt, and all members of society. We all share in this responsibility; none of us should fall short of being a reminder at times and a recipient of reminder at other times. This means that just as you remind others, you should never consider yourself above being reminded by someone else. Some people, when you come to remind them, may act arrogantly or believe they have no need for remembrance—such thinking is incorrect. We all need this, and we must remind one another, recognizing the importance of remembrance in our lives, especially in the time in which we live, where distractions and preoccupations have multiplied and increased. We all need to be reminded, and there is no book greater than this Book—whether through listening, reflection, understanding, recitation, memorization, study, knowledge, action, or da’wah (invitation to Islam).
Meaning of 'Not a Controller Over Them'
Allah says: "So remind, [O Muhammad]; you are only a reminder. You are not over them a controller." (Surah Al-Ghashiyah, 88:21-22)
The negation here is expressed with the particle " laysa" (لست) combined with the preposition "bi" (ب) connected to "musayṭir" (مسيطر). This is a single word and a solitary phrase within the verse, yet it negates numerous misconceptions that have been propagated by many Orientalists—both past and present—to accuse the message of the Quran and our Prophet ﷺ of coercing people into Islam through force, compelling them to enter the faith by witnessing that "there is no god but Allah." This verse is not abrogated; it is not superseded by verses commanding jihad. Rather, this verse is fundamentally established in the characteristics of the Quran’s message and its propagation: the primary means of conveying the Quran’s message is remembrance, not coercion.
When the Quran states: "You are not over them a controller," with the implication of dominance and control inherent in the word "musayṭir" (مسيطر)—which conveys notions of superiority, dominance, imposition, and forcing one’s will upon others, ensuring that their affairs align with one’s designs—this aligns perfectly with the meanings, values, principles, and actions encompassed by the concept of control. In this great verse, we must understand and recall that this blessed surah was revealed in the late Makkan period. We are on the cusp of the Madinan period, from which the Prophet ﷺ would emerge from Makkah to a place in Madinah where he would have supporters, defenders, and strength. He would possess greater capacity for response. Yet, the capacity established by the Quran in dozens of verses and texts is not a justification for controlling others or coercing them into Islam.
Faith is a conviction, an act of the heart first—of thought, of emotion—then an act of the limbs and behavior. It is absolutely inconsistent with the principle of coercion, force, or control, all of which the Quran negates regarding the most honorable of creation, the Prophet ﷺ, and the believers who follow him in this without doubt.
Quran's Message and Land Opening
Consider how we understand the message of the Quran. When the Muslims comprehended this message, they opened various lands not through force, the sword, or combat, but through their ethics, knowledge, manners, interactions, and da’wah (invitation). The conveyance of the Quran’s message is through invitation, not force. This is what the Quran negates regarding the most honorable of creation, the Prophet ﷺ, and the believers who follow him in this without doubt. This is the methodology we must understand and internalize. This verse is one of the fundamental principles of faith and da’wah. This verse is not abrogated by the command for jihad, self-defense, protection of Muslims, upholding justice, freedom, or human dignity. No, this is a fixed principle that does not change with circumstances.
This fixed principle is not because the Muslims, at the time this surah was revealed, were in a state of weakness, and when circumstances changed and strength increased, they resorted to controlling people’s minds and forcing them into faith. This is incorrect; it is a fabrication in reality.
The Concept of Control
The concept of control, with all it entails of dominance, force, and the imposition of one’s will on others, of superiority and hegemony, is a purely Western concept. This concept emerged with colonialism. Even among the well-known figures who have written on this, there is a scholar named Ramsay Muir, a prominent figure in the imperial expansionist school, who stated: "The only means by which Western civilization spread was colonialism, expansion, and colonization across all inhabited regions of the world."
His words reflect that Western civilization did not spread except through colonialism, which inherently involves the use of force, suppression of the desires and freedoms of peoples, destruction of their places of worship and rituals, and imposition of a single system upon them.
Continuation of Western Hegemony
Some may say, "But the era of colonialism is over, it has passed and gone." I say to them: No, its form has changed, its color has shifted, its manifestations have diversified, but it has not gone. In reality, humanity today lives in the depths of colonialism, hegemony, and Western control, which insists on imposing a single system—whether economic, social, intellectual, moral, or familial—on the entire world, East and West alike. Call it whatever you will.
Do you not see how this civilization seeks to impose its hegemony on the peoples of the world, turning them into replicas of its societal, familial, and intellectual maladies? Do you not see how it brandishes all forms of threat, coercion, control, and siege—even to the point of igniting wars and conflicts—if a nation opposes its intellectual system, which promotes deviation, propagates perversion, and normalizes abnormality?
Do you not see, morning and evening, how it imposes a single system through various media, refusing to accept anything but uniformity, even when the world’s peoples reject it? What is astonishing is that its arrogance, insolence, and presumption have grown to the point where it justifies these actions and laws under false pretenses and deceptive coverings: "freedom," "human rights."
O you who claim freedom and human rights, where is my right to adhere to the values in which I believe? Where is my right to affirm that Allah created the world with male and female, as my faith dictates? Where is my right to a value system consistent with my religion, customs, and traditions? The rights of peoples have been confiscated, and the arrogance of this civilization continues to swell day after day.
You ask me: Why has this control, hegemony, and arrogance emerged? The reality is that the Western mindset of conflict, control, and hegemony stems from a sense of superiority over other peoples—all others are inferior, do not understand, are barbarians, savages. You need only look to the books written on colonialism and its lasting legacy in the countries it once occupied, which remain colonized to this day.
These principles and values promote confrontation: the clash of civilizations, the clash of societies, the clash of values and peoples. The crisis of values plaguing the world is a direct result of the dominance of a single color and a single global system. This hegemony is utterly unacceptable—inside and out—according to the Quran. Hence, the verse states with a tone of superiority: "You are not a controller over them" (Al-Ghashiyah 88:22). This is a fundamental principle.
Meaning of 'Turning Away and Disbelieving'
Then comes the next verse: "Except for those who turn away and disbelieve" (Al-Ghashiyah 88:23). Here, the exception introduced by "except" is severed, meaning "but for those who turn away and disbelieve." Turning away (tawalli) refers to swift rejection. What happens to those who turn away from this Quran and this reminder? Reflect with me on the Quran: "Allah will punish them with the greatest punishment" (Al-Ghashiyah 88:24). This reinforces the earlier meaning: "Your duty is only to deliver the message, O Muhammad (ﷺ)." Those who turn away and disbelieve will be punished by Allah with the greatest punishment.
As for you, it was never required of you—in Mecca, Medina, or at any time—to force people into faith. If you did, it would no longer be faith, for faith is a matter of the heart. If the heart does not submit to faith, can it truly be called faith? That would be hypocrisy. Reflect on these profound meanings: "Allah will punish them with the greatest punishment" in the Hereafter. Is there a lesser punishment? The lesser punishment—less severe than the greatest—manifests in this world: natural disasters, diseases, famines, inflation, calamities.
This verse is not merely a warning to those stubborn deniers. In reality, it contains a form of profound and eloquent miracle. Reflect with me: "Those who turn away and disbelieve"—no, in other verses, the lesser punishment in this world is explained as resulting from what? From various calamities.
The Consequences of Turning Away from Allah’s Guidance
What are the results and ultimate outcomes of turning away from the Quran’s guidance? "Corruption has appeared throughout the land and sea in consequence of what the hands of people have earned" (Ar-Rum 30:41). Increased corruption, rising cost of living, scarcity of provisions, wars, conflicts, fires, destruction, disasters, diseases—and more besides.
You ask: What is the connection between turning away from Allah’s guidance and these calamities? I say to you: It is the increase in injustice. Turning away from Allah’s method—His guidance, which contains goodness, righteousness, justice, and fairness—means that people no longer uphold justice for others as they do for themselves. When faith in Allah the Exalted weakens and His authority over the human conscience diminishes, what is the result? Increased corruption, the monopolization of humanity’s resources by certain individuals or groups, the commodification of people’s sustenance and lives, the rise of war profiteers, the fomenting of discord, conflicts, and strife. You will see class stratification solidify in the world: some who hoard wealth they know not what to do with, and others who cannot even find their daily bread.
This is what follows from turning away from the guidance of the Great Quran—the guidance that addresses Allah’s servants, saying: "Indeed, Allah orders justice, excellence, and giving to relatives, and forbids immorality, evil, and oppression" (An-Nahl 16:90). Reflect with me on the connection between this and: "So remind, for you are only a reminder" (Al-Ghashiyah 88:21). When humanity turns away and rejects this guidance, what is the result? The lesser and the greater punishment. The greater punishment is certain, as stated: "Allah will punish them with the greatest punishment"—and this punishment is not in anyone’s hands. The lesser punishment, however, follows from turning away from Allah’s guidance and disbelief.
Return and Reckoning
And the result said: "Indeed, to Us is their return," and al-Īāb (return) is the permanent and unchanging return. This means that this return has no subsequent return to the worldly life. With every implication of the word al-Īāb comes a warning to these disbelievers: "You will not return to the world." He said: "Indeed," with certainty, "to Us is their return."
What is your role, O Muhammad (ﷺ)? Your role is al-Tadhkirah (remembrance and admonition): "So remind, [O Muhammad], with the Qur'an those who fear My threat." This role is stipulated in numerous verses of Allah’s Book, including this verse: "So remind, for you are only a reminder. You are not over them a controller." Many of these verses were revealed during the Meccan period, but the Medinan period did not abolish this command. On the contrary, it remains a principal aspect of the Prophet’s (ﷺ) message and call, as well as that of every believer who follows his message: al-Tadhkirah (remembrance and admonition).
"Indeed, to Us is their return," He said: "Then upon Us is their account." Reflect on the use of "Upon Us" in "their account." The reckoning is so that they may understand. Humanity must realize that the matter is not one of chaos without account or record—your deeds are being recorded for you.
These fundamental principles and values in the message of the Qur'an are what made Islamic civilization a civilization of humility. By humility here, I mean refraining from arrogance toward others, nations, or the world, despite their certainty that they surpassed the peoples of their time in faith, conviction, values, principles, and the sciences, knowledge, and civilizations they attained.
Despite this superiority, they opened the doors of their universities and knowledge to every seeker of knowledge, regardless of their identity, beliefs, lineage, or religion. Why? This is the pinnacle of the faith-based and Qur'anic values brought by the message of the Qur'an. These are not transient instructions that change with the shifts between the Meccan and Medinan periods, nor between times of strength or weakness. Never.
When Muslims truly understood the message of the Qur'an, they understood it correctly even in the height of their power. They were never arrogant, domineering, or usurpers of the resources of other peoples. The evidence for this is too numerous to count or enumerate. For example, Adam Mez, Thomas Arnold, and many other fair-minded Western Orientalists have all stated one thing: churches and places of worship remained preserved throughout the Islamic ages—they were neither destroyed nor demolished, nor were their symbols broken. People were left free in their beliefs, worship, and expression of faith.
This stems from a religion, a Book, and a methodology that does not impose control over others, nor does it usurp their freedom of belief, worship, or expression. Who, then, is the controller in our world? Who is the controller? Who are the shepherds of control, hegemony, and the usurpation of the freedoms and rights of peoples and individuals? Is it those who follow this Qur'an, or is it those who turn away from it and disregard it?
"Indeed, to Us is their return, then upon Us is their account," so that the world may understand and grasp that the logic of force, racism, empty hegemony, and the usurpation of the rights and freedoms of peoples will not pass without reckoning or punishment.
"Indeed, to Us is their return," where there is no return to the worldly life, but rather permanence in the Hereafter, "then upon Us is their account."
May the peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you.